|
Post by chris135ex on Mar 16, 2023 11:07:33 GMT
I have an Audi s3 8v and I need to reset the new Haldex pump I’m going to fit soon. Can I do this with my obd11 ?
|
|
|
Post by dv52 (Australia) on Mar 16, 2023 21:27:41 GMT
Chris: Ain't nothing magic about non OBD11 diagnostic devices (like VCDS)!!! With very few exceptions (maybe none), if a procedure can be done with VCDS, it can also be done with OBD11 - because these procedures are largely undertaken by the module itself!! So from memory and my patchy notes (I haven't done this process for a while), the re-learning procedure for the Haldex pump on a MQB platform car like an Audi A3 8V should be like this:
- Start the engine and wait for normal engine temperature (i.e. 90°C on dashboard temp gauge)
- Insert the OBD11 dongle into the car's OBD port and fire-up/connect to the OBD11 software
- Navigate to the 22 All Wheel Control module
- Scroll-down to Live Data
- Select Pump calibration values. A non-zero string indicates that the pump requires initialization -if so, proceed to next step
- Exit Live Data, scroll-down the screen and select Basic Setting
- Select Pump Motor and click-on the Pump-Motor drop-down menu
- Select All adaption values (it's the only option) and click-on Start
- WAIT for the procedure to complete - the process takes about 1-2 minutes. During this period, you should hear the pump priming the Hadex system a couple of times (the pump pressurizes to about 40 Bar, then de-pressurizes - see the pressure-trace for pump calibration HERE)
- Exit OBD11 software
- Cycle ignition key and repeat steps 1 - 5 above. If the procedure has been successful, the Pump calibration values should be reported as a zero-string
- Clear any faults that might remain from the physical pump replacement task in 22 All Wheel Control module
- Exit OBD11 and drive-car. Check for wheel-spin under hard acceleration conditions
Don
|
|
|
Post by stefb32 on Oct 2, 2023 11:08:09 GMT
Hi new here , but I’m going to be fitting a new Haldex pump and I’m gonna use my OBDeleven to do the relearn process but it comes up with channel what do I need to type in Cheers
|
|
|
Post by dv52 (Australia) on Oct 3, 2023 0:02:56 GMT
stefb32 : hmm........ "it comes up with channel"!! What does this mean - are you saying that the module requests a channel number?
If so, then your module does NOT have UDS/ODX protocol - which means that it is NOT an Audi A3 8V. So posting your question on this part of the forum is NOT appropriate. What model/type car is this?
Don
|
|
|
Post by dancupra on Nov 4, 2023 13:48:18 GMT
Chris: Ain't nothing magic about non OBD11 diagnostic devices (like VCDS)!!! With very few exceptions (maybe none), if a procedure can be done with VCDS, it can also be done with OBD11 - because these procedures are largely undertaken by the module itself!! So from memory and my patchy notes (I haven't done this process for a while), the re-learning procedure for the Haldex pump on a MQB platform car like an Audi A3 8V should be like this:
- Start the engine and wait for normal engine temperature (i.e. 90°C on dashboard temp gauge)
- Insert the OBD11 dongle into the car's OBD port and fire-up/connect to the OBD11 software
- Navigate to the 22 All Wheel Control module
- Scroll-down to Live Data
- Select Pump calibration values. A non-zero string indicates that the pump requires initialization -if so, proceed to next step
- Exit Live Data, scroll-down the screen and select Basic Setting
- Select Pump Motor and click-on the Pump-Motor drop-down menu
- Select All adaption values (it's the only option) and click-on Start
- WAIT for the procedure to complete - the process takes about 1-2 minutes. During this period, you should hear the pump priming the Hadex system a couple of times (the pump pressurizes to about 40 Bar, then de-pressurizes - see the pressure-trace for pump calibration HERE)
- Exit OBD11 software
- Cycle ignition key and repeat steps 1 - 5 above. If the procedure has been successful, the Pump calibration values should be reported as a zero-string
- Clear any faults that might remain from the physical pump replacement task in 22 All Wheel Control module
- Exit OBD11 and drive-car. Check for wheel-spin under hard acceleration conditions
Don Hi Don, Just tried the relearning procedure following your steps and using OBD11 Pro plan, however “Function not available” message popped after starting the sequence. Same platform, same Haldex type like most of the VAG cars, I wonder why is not supported on my car :Cupra Formentor VZ AWD 2.0 TSI. Any ideas ?
|
|
|
Post by dv52 (Australia) on Nov 4, 2023 20:20:36 GMT
dan: Hi.
The cars on this part of the forum are built on a MQB platform (5Q0/3Q0 chassis)- however, a Cupra Formentor VZ has a MQB-evo platform and it has a 5WA chassis. There are similarities between the two set-ups - but the CAN bus arrangement is very different!
I've never tried the procedure above on a MQB-evo vehicle - I suspect that it might be problematic!!
Don
|
|
|
Post by dancupra on Nov 4, 2023 21:55:56 GMT
Hi Don,
Thank you for your reply. Of course it had to be slightly different MQB-evo (learning something everyday)
I wonder if OBD11 team might help with that ?! It’s one of the reasons I went for OBD11.
|
|
paulz
New Member
Posts: 5
|
Post by paulz on Mar 24, 2024 1:21:35 GMT
dan: Hi. The cars on this part of the forum are built on a MQB platform (5Q0/3Q0 chassis)- however, a Cupra Formentor VZ has a MQB-evo platform and it has a 5WA chassis. There are similarities between the two set-ups - but the CAN bus arrangement is very different! I've never tried the procedure above on a MQB-evo vehicle - I suspect that it might be problematic!! Don Hello This thread seems closest to my question. Do you know if obdeleven supports the pre-UDS controller basic settings to clear adaptation values and run the pump calibration? Specifically I want to do the relearn on a gen4 haldex on a 2013 Passat TDI. I have established that the controller is pre-UDS, and will buy obdeleven if it can do these basic settings.
|
|
|
Post by dv52 (Australia) on Mar 24, 2024 5:35:59 GMT
While this forum is sponsored by OBD11, it's mostly populated by users. My suggestion is that you contact the deities on the OBD11 mother-ship and ask you question there - try the normal email support@obdeleven.com -it's monitored
That said, I had assumed from your words that a 2011 Passat B7 has a K-line (KWP2000) communication protocol. However, according to the Self Study Program for this car ( SSP-488), which you can download HERE- the comms arrangement looks very much like the normal CAN bus. If a MY13 Passat has a newer chassis build than 2011- then it's almost certain to have the later CAN bus arrangement as well
But, I know nothing about this car - so likely I'm missing something!!
Don
|
|
paulz
New Member
Posts: 5
|
Post by paulz on Mar 26, 2024 11:06:14 GMT
Thanks for your response.
I think my car has a mix of protocols - it was a time when controllers were transitioning to UDS. They all use CAN bus as a base.
My current scan tool (an Ancel VD700, which has been surprisingly useful) reports the controller protocol as simply 'CAN20'. The VD700 can even 'see' active channels under basic settings - reporting channels at 20, 40, 41, 50, 51 and 97. So if I knew which channel number corresponded to which basic setting, I would try it out. But going in blind, I really dont want to risk it. Ive spend ages on google looking for this and only found one - apparently 51 is 'Adjustment value controlling the opening degree of the clutch'.
I have some confidence that in VCDS, there would be a corresponding label file (their terminology) which gives a description of a selected channel. Similarly, I feel pretty confident that obdeleven will be able to see the channels, its whether they have implemented a description for each one.
I did chat to help, and they would not talk specifically to my question, nor escalate my question to the technical team, just assured me that I 'should' be able to do with obdeleven what I could do with VCDS.
|
|
|
Post by dv52 (Australia) on Mar 26, 2024 21:52:55 GMT
paulz : I've been a long time user of both VCDS and OBD11 and I have NOT found anything that OBD11 can't do (and VCDS can do)! In fact, quite the opposite - VCDS can't access modules that use SFD protection protocols (which applies to the latest VAG fleet) - but OBD11 can access these cars! There's lots of nonsense-mystique about VCDS (and it is a very good diagnostic tool) - but I wouldn't rate it above OBD11. Truth is that both diagnostic devices have their merits and disadvantages, which ultimately are nothing more than personal preferences So, bottom line = I suspect the OBD11 help-desk advice is correct!! Note: I am a volunteer here - I have absolutely NO connection to the deities on the OBD11 mother-ship (so, I have NO secret agenda when providing advice) I was an active participant on the Ross-Tech forum for many years until Uwe Ross censored my views on methods to stop the senseless massacre of innocent school children in USA.
Uwe has ultra-right wing views on American gun control and US second amendment rights (the main banner on the Ross-Tech website has crossed-rifles against the American fag as a statement of the corporate value-set that the owner imposes on the company)
Don't get me wrong, Uwe is entitled to his views (as are ALL Americans) - but the Ross-Tech forum is a public forum and holding different views on US gun culture does NOT constitute a forum offense - IMO, of course!
Anyhow, rant over. If you still want to consider VCDS - go to the VCDS Forum main page and select the Pre-Sales support sub-forum. This is a portion of the Ross-Tech forum that allows prospective VCDS users to ask questions like yours. You don't need to have purchased VCDS - but you will need to register (I suggest that you don't mention this discussion - I'm proudly persona non grata)
Finally - you might find this self-study-program of interest - it's about the version Haldex system that is connected to K-line: K-line Haldex (see pages 36 & 37)
My apology for not being of more help - but as I have said, I just don't know much about these early model cars
Don
|
|
paulz
New Member
Posts: 5
|
Post by paulz on Mar 26, 2024 22:57:01 GMT
paulz : I've been a long time user of both VCDS and OBD11 and I have NOT found anything that OBD11 can't do (and VCDS can do)! In fact, quite the opposite - VCDS can't access modules that use SFD protection protocols (which applies to the latest VAG fleet) - but OBD11 can access these cars! There's lots of nonsense-mystique about VCDS (and it is a very good diagnostic tool) - but I wouldn't rate it above OBD11. Truth is that both diagnostic devices have their merits and disadvantages, which ultimately are nothing more than personal preferences So, bottom line = I suspect the OBD11 help-desk advice is correct!! Note: I am a volunteer here - I have absolutely NO connection to the deities on the OBD11 mother-ship (so, I have NO secret agenda when providing advice) I was an active participant on the Ross-Tech forum for many years until Uwe Ross censored my views on methods to stop the senseless massacre of innocent school children in USA.
Uwe has ultra-right wing views on American gun control and US second amendment rights (the main banner on the Ross-Tech website has crossed-rifles against the American fag as a statement of the corporate value-set that the owner imposes on the company)
Don't get me wrong, Uwe is entitled to his views (as are ALL Americans) - but the Ross-Tech forum is a public forum and holding different views on US gun culture does NOT constitute a forum offense - IMO, of course!
Anyhow, rant over. If you still want to consider VCDS - go to the VCDS Forum main page and select the Pre-Sales support sub-forum. This is a portion of the Ross-Tech forum that allows prospective VCDS users to ask questions like yours. You don't need to have purchased VCDS - but you will need to register (I suggest that you don't mention this discussion - I'm proudly persona non grata)
Finally - you might find this self-study-program of interest - it's about the version Haldex system that is connected to K-line: K-line Haldex (see pages 36 & 37)
My apology for not being of more help - but as I have said, I just don't know much about these early model cars
Don
Thanks. I think you've pushed me over the line to just order obdeleven and have done with it. I would say it does have some distinct advantages that set it apart, like the ability to launch tests from outside (or under!) the vehicle. VCDS seems to be better for serious diagnosis with eg graphing. I don't have any mystical views about the power of VCDS - it's just data, after all. But it has been around for an awfully long time, and as I understand, its many users have contributed to the knowledge base (label files for different controllers etc). So it stands to reason that its data would be more complete, particularly for older models. I'm surprised there has not been an open-source tool with the same capabilities. The sticking point is of course all of the secret/proprietary data locked up in the tool, and people seem to think that it's now the intellectual property of Ross-tech. I dont know the legalities, but it was pretty clearly all ultimately obtained from VAG group manuals, by reverse engineering ODIS, or by 'crowd-sourcing' as mentioned. I'm Australian too, so you dont need to convince me about the advantages of gun control. Leaving aside the mass shootings, the sheer availability of guns means that suicide, accident, and 'crimes of passion' are greatly facilitated in the US. And politics? There is no middle ground any more it seems. Thanks again, Paul.
|
|
|
Post by dv52 (Australia) on Mar 27, 2024 22:50:07 GMT
Thanks. I think you've pushed me over the line to just order obdeleven and have done with it. I would say it does have some distinct advantages that set it apart, like the ability to launch tests from outside (or under!) the vehicle. VCDS seems to be better for serious diagnosis with eg graphing. Hmm...... as I said - it's swings and roundabouts - the differences between the two diagnostic devices are mostly value-based (meaning, ultimately personal preferences). It IS possible to graph the Live data stream in OBD11 - it just involves another step that isn't needed in VCDS!
A BIG difference between the two devices is the underpinning topography (meaning the fundamental design principle).
For VCDS - the software that is loaded is COMPLETE - this means that every-time there is an update (and updates are regular), the user must download the latest release software PLUS Ross-Tech's entire database for EVERY vehicle that VCDS supports (regardless of what cars the user will need). This means that Ross-Tech's IP is effectively in the public domain (which ain't a good design decision by Uwe's Ross). Yes, Ross-Tech attempts to encrypt the VCDS database - but the proliferation of pirate copies (even with the latest software) is evidence that Uwe's stubbornness to retain an out-of-date topology really isn't working in the 21st century!
OBD11 on the other hand uses an entirely different topology - for this device, the ONLY software that the user downloads is the potion that uniquely applies to the car to which the dongle is connected. This is a far more efficient set-up and it means that the OBD11 IP largely remains behind the firewall on their central server.
On the down-side, the OBD11 user experience is fundamentally linked to the quality of the ISP performance - because a diagnostic session involves lots of communicates to-and-from the VOLTAS central servers.
So - a vital aspect of the decision to purchase OBD11 is the quality of internet reception at the location of use. If the car is garaged in the bowels of a deep subterranean car -park, maybe OBD11 isn't the best choice?
I don't have any mystical views about the power of VCDS - it's just data, after all. But it has been around for an awfully long time, and as I understand, its many users have contributed to the knowledge base (label files for different controllers etc). So it stands to reason that its data would be more complete, particularly for older models. I'm surprised there has not been an open-source tool with the same capabilities. The sticking point is of course all of the secret/proprietary data locked up in the tool, and people seem to think that it's now the intellectual property of Ross-tech. I dont know the legalities, but it was pretty clearly all ultimately obtained from VAG group manuals, by reverse engineering ODIS, or by 'crowd-sourcing' as mentioned. Yes, from my time on the VCDS forum and from Ross-Tech employees, I became aware of a corporate tension between Ross-Tech and the VAG group. My sense is that there was (and still is) a strong awareness by Ross-Tech of the legal issues regarding VW's IP!
In contrast, VOLTAS IT (the parent company for OBD11) has lauded it's close relationship with the VAG Group from the start of OBD11 build - it marketed the fact that OBD11 was developed with authorization by the VAG Group under a legal agreement (as I understand)
I'm Australian too, so you dont need to convince me about the advantages of gun control. Leaving aside the mass shootings, the sheer availability of guns means that suicide, accident, and 'crimes of passion' are greatly facilitated in the US. And politics? There is no middle ground any more it seems. Arrhhh........ so G'day cobber!!. Your words reminded me of Uwe's principal argument about the number of weapons openly available in a community "it's not the guns that cause massacres - it's the people". This naive and self-serving response is directly from the NRA hymn-book. Patriots scare the be-jusus out of me!!
|
|
paulz
New Member
Posts: 5
|
Post by paulz on Apr 10, 2024 2:46:03 GMT
Hmm. So I recieved the obdeleven and I'm not much more advanced. Protocol confirmed as KWP (in fact after looking at a few controllers, only the engine module seems to be UDS - I expected to see more for a 2013 model. I would not be surprised if VW used up (ie dumped) their old stock of KWP controllers on the Australian market during the transition.
There are no output tests exposed at all - same as my Ancel VD700. There is only one basic setting exposed at channel 51 - adjustment value for angle of valve (or words to that effect). I actually found this one online in an old document, but dont know if it will do the relearn function or not.
I read somewhere that adaptations channel zero will clear all adaptation values, and I wonder if this will have the same effect as the clear pump adaptation values basic setting for the UDS controller. Again, there are more basic settings channels that exist - 20, 40, 41, 50, 51 and 97. But not documented.
This is what I had feared, and the difference from VCDS - a lot more user input for a lot more cars. Obdeleven also relies on user-generated labels, and a warning about the reliability of the labels comes up before it loads the labels. I had not known about this, and hoped after our last exchange that their 'relationship' with VW would mean they had inside knowledge.
No direct way to prime the pump, so I guess I will just run the car after first fill for a while and check that the pump runs, then top up.
I really dont want to spend yet another $AU400+ on VCDS for this one job. I doubt a dealer will help - they would probably charge the full amount of the service just for configuring the pump, if I know Australian VW dealerships, or just tell me to go to hell. I might try a chinese knock-off fo this one job, since my Ancel works for all other common service items.
|
|
|
Post by kevinkleyn on May 28, 2024 11:23:45 GMT
I literally just created an account to say thank you for the solution Don.
I've been struggling for nearly a year, and just like that, I did my first wheelspin'less launch today since I got my S3.
It's pretty hectic lol.
Thank you Don!!
|
|